The aim of this article is to reflect upon the differences and similarities between the group that is called ‘The Seeders’ or the Intergalactic Confederation (1) in the work of Elena Danaan and those that are called ‘The Guardians’ in the work of Ashayana Deane. Would they be the same group, or not?

I was triggered to write this post after someone in Elena Danaan’s new Public Chat Group (2) referred to the fifth season of Star Trek Discovery (3) where this theme of a ‘Seeder’ group also seems to play a role. Of course I will give you no spoilers here; better watch it yourself.

ASHAYANA DEANE AND THE GUARDIANS
The work of Ashayana Deane appears occasionally on this website, but not very often (4). I think it is quite intriguing, but also quite complex. That doesn’t mean we cannot engage in a comparison once in a while with the Elena Danaan paradigm.

Let’s start off with a drawing of what are called ‘The Guardians‘ (5) in her work. You can see names like Zionite, Aethein, Lyran-Sirian Elder, Queventellior, Turaneusian-1 (Azara), hybrid Zionite-Human, Jonathan (One of the Priests of Ur), Dralov (Arcturian), Amera Zeta Grey, Ranthunkeana.

When you look at this group of Guardians you can see insectoids, humanoids, Grays. I can’t identify any Reptilians.

The Guardian Alliance was “created by the IAFW 570-568 million years ago, during the restatement of the Emerald Covenant during which the Oraphim-Angelic Human lineage was created.” (5, p.61)

ELENA DANAAN AND THE SEEDERS
In a video on dr. Salla’s site (6) Thor Han gives a short description of the Seeders: “They are our forefathers. They seeded us, here in Nataru [our Milky Way Galaxy]. Terra, like a few other places in this galaxy, has been for a long while one of their particularly loved grounds for experimentation about human development and consciousness. Such as in Mana (K62-Lyra). They are the seeders.”

Elena describes the 24 (or at least 21 of them) in her third disclosure book (7). You can read more about them at (1). What is relevant in the current context is that these species all come from other galaxies. There are insectoids, reptiloids, humanoids amongst them.

COMPARING THE GUARDIANS AND THE SEEDERS
I am far from a specialist in the Ashayana Deane (or Lisa Renée) material. I have been working extensively with ED’s material the last couple of years so I do think I know quite a bit about her perspective.

When comparing the two pictures and their descriptions I can only come to one conclusion: they are not the same. Not only do they look very differently, their names are different, but their origin is also different.

Whereas the Seeders are (almost by definition) NOT from this galaxy, some of the Guardians apparently are. You can hear about Guardians coming from Lyra, Sirius and Arcturus. I don’t know where some of the others come from. They might have their origin in other galaxies. If anyone can tell us more about them, please do so.

SOME REFLECTIONS
The Guardians would have been created some 568 million years ago. When would the various Seeder Races have been ‘created’ and by whom? Do the Guardians also work with Emissaries? Was Ashayana Deane one of their Emissaries? Like I said I don’t have a lot of understanding of Deane’s work, so perhaps I am drawing conclusions a bit too fast here, but you also don’t need to be meteorologist to know when it it raining (9)

FOOTNOTES
(1) The Intergalactic Confederation
(2) On May 28, 2024 Elena Danaan opened a public chat room on Telegram. She introduced it as such: “Welcome to this safe place where you can share your opinion on my materiel and connect with kindred spirited people. Share in this new public chat room any information, messages & requests you wish to communicate to me or to the star people. Respectful language and civilized behavior is of course a requirement. Vulgarity and slandering (of anyone) will be booted out. Let us build together a higher density future, on the frequency of compassion” (t.me/ElenaDanaanOfficialChat)
(3) Star Trek Discovery on IMDB

(4) You can find a collection of all the articles that deal with the work of Ashayana Deane in the Galactic Anthropology Library. You can also just do a search in the menu on her name. We also have a separate thread on her in the Galactic Anthropology Study Group
(5) Deane, A. (2001) Voyagers I: The Sleeping Abductees – I added the image twice because Telegram often selects the bottom image as the thumbnail for an article. I didn’t want the Meteorologist joke to become the thumbnail for this Seeders and Guardians post. That’s why.
(6) Earth Alliance Mission to Ganymede to greet ET visitors & inaugurate a Star Trek Future
(7) Danaan, E. (2022) The Seeders.
(8) Contact with the Council of Nine and 24 ET Seeder Races
(9) (from the) Funnies category of the Laura Aboli Archive (join us there)